present or past tense: [it is sunny. you are sitting] vs [it was sunny. you were sitting]

English grammar questions, answered by Alan

Moderator: Alan

Locked
ansonman
Top
Top
Posts: 159
Joined: Mon May 18, 2020 9:18 pm
Status: Learner of English

present or past tense: [it is sunny. you are sitting] vs [it was sunny. you were sitting]

Post by ansonman »

Suppose that you and your friends went to a public event last month. While all of you were there, you made some videos of them.

(1) (My friends and I are now watching one of the videos.) I say to my friends, "Look. It is sunny on the left side but you are sitting under a tree on the right side. Why didn't you sit on the left to enjoy the sun?"

(2) (My friends and I are now watching one of the videos.) I say to my friends, "Look. It was sunny on the left side but you were sitting under a tree on the right side. Why didn't you sit on the left to enjoy the sun?"

Some of my friends think (2) is correct because the past tense of the phrases "was sunny ... were sitting" is consistent with the past tense of the question "why didn't you sit....".

However, my other friends don't agree with them. They believe (1) is correct by saying that because you are watching the video right now, you can use the "historical present'' for " it is sunny and your are sitting". It is okay to ask the question "why didn't you sit..." in the past tense because you are talking about why you didn't do so when you were at the event.

Is it okay to use the historical present in the context where you are now talking about something in the video that happened in the past? Thank you for your help.
User avatar
Alan
Teacher/Moderator
Teacher/Moderator
Posts: 15311
Joined: Mon Dec 29, 2003 7:56 pm
Status: Teacher of English
Location: Japan

Re: present or past tense: [it is sunny. you are sitting] vs [it was sunny. you were sitting]

Post by Alan »

Yes, a historic present would be a perfectly acceptable substitute for a past tense in such circumstances.
Locked