conditional negative questions: if he has time, why doesn't he come?

Members help members on grammar, vocab, pronunciation...

Moderator: EC

Post Reply
User avatar
gimletful
Member
Posts: 1
Joined: Sun Mar 13, 2022 1:09 pm
Status: Teacher of English
Location: Kunming Yunnan China

conditional negative questions: if he has time, why doesn't he come?

Post by gimletful »

Hello,
i read a sentence today:
if he has time why doesn't he come?

i know that in zero conditional sentences, both "if" clause and main clause need to use present simple, but this sentence simply doesn't belong to zero conditional right?

later i checked about the first conditional, according to 1st conditional, it should be:
if he has time why won't he come?

so i am very confused :?: , which one is right?
if he has time why doesn't he come?
if he has time why won't he come?

cheers
User avatar
GameEnglish
Member
Posts: 8
Joined: Mon Sep 26, 2022 2:01 pm
Status: Teacher of English
Location: Germany

Re: conditional negative questions: if he has time, why doesn't he come?

Post by GameEnglish »

Both of those sentences are correct, they are just used in slightly different situations.

If he has time, why doesn't he come?

can be used if we are talking about a recurring event, say football practice on Saturdays.

If he has time, why won't he come?

could be used as well to talk about someone who doesn't want to come to football practice, but it can also be use for a single event. E.g. if he has time, why won't he come to the party tonight?

Don't worry too much about fitting conditionals into the patterns given by the 1st conditional, 2nd conditional etc. They don't really exist, and are just used as teaching tools. You can actually mix the patterns up more than you'd think.
www.gameenglish.com
Text adventures and reading games for learning English.
Post Reply